« Joe Kraus’ Caller ID Test | McClure on Scaling Venture Capital »

Do You Need To File A Form D With A Financing?

It used to be the case that whenever a private company did a financing, it filed a Form D with the SEC in order to comply with Regulation D. Suddenly, I’m hearing of lots of situations, especially in seed and Series A financings, where companies are no longer filing Form D. Apparently a number of law firms have decided that a Form D filing is no longer mandatory. After checking with some entrepreneurs who haven’t filed a Form D, their motivation is that they want to keep their financing “secret” so they can stay in a stealth mode for longer.

Jason Mendelson just wrote a post on his blog titled Why is Everyone Hatin’ on Form D? In it he explains the groundrules.

Regulation D requires a filing, but per Rule 507, if you don’t file it, doesn’t eliminate your ability to rely on RegD for the financing.   Therefore a company that wants to be stealth and elects against the advice not to file the Form D is violating an SEC rule, but it doesn’t jeopardize the offering exemption.  4(2) always exists, but that is factual, and in these very early rounds you may have small angels or others who are tricky.

Jason goes on to explain the implications and downsides of not filing. In the comments, Bart Dillashaw weighs in on the best reason to file Form D (it preempts all of the individual state securities laws and regulations.)

Both Jason and I feel strongly you should just suck it up and file Form D. I am completely confused by the advice some lawyers are giving about the reasons not to file. And I am concerned that some VCs are supporting what we think is bad legal advice and this will ultimately come back to haunt some entrepreneurs.

August 14th, 2012 by     Categories: Legal     Tags: , , , ,
  • http://siliconhillslawyer.com/ José A

    We occasionally get a client who insists on not filing a Form D, but definitely in agreement that not filing should be a very narrow exception, not the rule. I think most entrepreneurs today know that staying stealth is counterproductive anyway.

  • http://www.facebook.com/richard.rodman.71 Richard Rodman

    This is some great advice. Filing a Form D is essential.

  • Pingback: Motivation: tracking startup funding in the Bay Area | Silicon Valley Funding Map

  • Penguiny

    In follow-on rounds, there is typically something hiding in an agreement somewhere that asks the issuing company to represent and warrant that they have complied with the securities laws in the past. Companies that fail to file their Form D can’t sign that rep. In the end, they either have to get an explicit waiver of the rep for their failure to file the Form D, or else go back and late-file or take corrective action. I’ve seen this eat most of the benefit of the next round of financing.

    Issuers with lawyers have an additional problem when they skip out on Form D. The willful failure to file may be criminal, and in any event may disqualify the issuer from future use of the Reg D exemptions. And state regulators treat late-filed or unfiled Forms D with prejudice, usually levying ugly fines or worse. It is tough to claim that the failure to file was innocent when the issuer was paying a lawyer to advise them with regard to it.