« What Kind of Benefits Can I Expect Working at a Startup? | Main | More Thoughts on Structuring an Angel Investment »

June 8, 2008 3:59 PM

Founders Termination Clause In Term Sheets?

Q: Thank you very much for your term sheet series.  Not being that familiar with "specific" term sheets, I have heard something about VC terms that effectively allow the VC to fire the founder(s) and in the process relieve them of their shares since they had then left the company before liquidity. I have read a previous Ask the VC post about the 'moral' and 'reputation' reasons that VC's will not do this.

However I am more interested in the legal binds and would like to know if these sort of terms are something that is standard/negotiable in various term sheets.

A: (Jason).  There is certainly nothing in a standard term sheet that specifically addresses this.  I've seen founder / CEO termination clauses in term sheets that effectively say "if X, Y and Z doesn't happen, you are fired."  I've always found these to be egregious and worse yet, sets up the VC and founder / CEO to be enemies, not collaborators trying to help the company be successful. 

As for different mechanics that a VC might use to remove a founder / CEO / founders, etc.:

1.  Board control - if the VC has board control, or the ability to elect a majority of the board, terminating founders and / or executives is fairly simple;

2.  Voting rights - be careful that there aren't any non-standard control provisions in the voting rights that allow the VCs to vote people "off the island."

As far as acquiring the terminated party's shares, I've never seen a VC with a contractual right to be able to do this.  I've seen some documents which gives the shares back to the company, but never the VC.

And shares going back to the company is rare as well, so long as we are talking shares that have vested under a option plan or are not subject to some sort of repurchase.  Those shares should be free and clear the property of the terminated party.

Posted in: Founders | Posted by: Jason Mendelson
Boulder Open Coffee Club
Next Event
- The Cup
8 a.m.

VC Bloggers

Brad Feld
Jason Mendelson

Andrew Parker (USV)
Ask The VC
Baris Karadogan (Velocity)
Bijan Sabet (Spark)
Bill Burnham (Inductive)
Chris Fralic (First Round)
Christine Herron (First Round)
Dan Rua (Inflexion)
Daniel Cohen (Gemini)
David Beisel (Venrock)
David Cowan (Bessemer)
David Dufresne (JLA)
David Hornik (August)
Ed Sim (Dawntreader)
Eric Friedman (USV)
Foundry Group
Fred Destin (Atlas)
Fred Wilson (USV)
George Zachary (CRV)
Golden Horn Ventures
Guy Kawasaki (Garage)
Highway 12 Ventures
J Chen (CXO)
Jacob Ner-David (Jerusalem)
Jason Ball (Qualcomm)
Jeff Bussgang (Flybridge)
Jeff Clavier (SoftTech)
Jeff Joseph (Prescient)
Jeremy Levine (Bessemer)
John Thornton
Jonathan Seeber (Updata)
Josh Kopelman (First Round)
Justin Label (Bessemer)
Keith Benjamin (Levensohn)
Ken Gaebler (Gaebler)
Marc Averitt (Okapi)
Mark Davis (DFJ Gotham)
Mark Suster (GRP)
Matt McCall (DFJ Portage)
Matt Winn (Chrysalis)
Max Bleyleben (Kennet)
Michael Feinstein (Sempre)
Momentum Venture Management
Nic Brisbourn (DFJ Esprit)
Pascal Levensohn (Levensohn)
Paul Fisher (Advent)
Paul Jozefak (Neuhaus)
Paul Kedrosky (Ventures West)
PE Hub Blog
Philippe Botteri (Bessemer)
Rajil Kapoor (Mayfield)
Rich Moran (Venrock)
Richard Dale (Sigma)
Rick Segal (JLA)
Rob Day (@Ventures)
Rob Finn (Edison)
Rob Hayes (First Round)
Rob Schultz (IllinoisVENTURES)
Robert Goldberg (YL)
Ryan McIntyre (Foundry)
Sagi Rubin (Virgin)
Sarah Tavel (Bessemer)
Saul Klein (Index)
Seth Levine (Foundry)
Shantanu Bhagwat (Amadeus)
Sid Mohasseb (Venture Farm)
Simeon Simeonov (Polaris)
Steve Brotman (Greenhill)
Steve Jurvetson (DFJ)
Stu Phillips (Ridgelift)
Stuart Ellman and Eric Wiesen (RRE)
T.D. Klein (Legend)
TechFund Europe
Todd Dagres (Spark)
Tom Cole (Trinity)
Union Square Ventures
Vineet Buch (BlueRun)